What’s Wrong With This Picture?

As it says in the “About” page of this blog, I’ve been “organic” since 1994.  As these things go, that sounds fairly progressive now, but if you read further, you read that I stopped using pesticides to attract more butterflies to my property.  Along the way, I discovered that in the process of making a welcoming home for butterflies, I was actually creating a pretty nice place to live for all manner of other things, especially song birds.  These lovely birds, with their equally lovely songs, have helped me keep my insect population in check.  What’s not to like?

Interestingly enough, some very big name agriculture interests conducted a study about organic farming recently.    Mark Bittman wrote about it in the New York Times.  But as Bittman said in his opinion pice, this study–and it was a big one–has gotten almost no publicity.  So if that’s the case, how will anything change?  So here’s my attempt at helping.

The verdict?  Not only does organic farming work (gee, what a surprise), but it can work just about as profitably as modern-day farming, with it dependence on genetically modified seeds, and heavy doses of pesticides and artificial fertilizers.

What’s changed in the equation?  The addition of livestock.  That provides the manure–i.e., the “fertilizer”–for the organic farms.

Oh yes, a few other things changed too.  There is no rote reliance on schedules of fertilizers or pesticides, organic or otherwise.  There is an almost slavish insistence on observation (something I am always insisting upon when I lecture.  “Look at your plants.  Watch your plants. Know your plants and what’s normal for them.  They’ll tell you when something’s wrong long before you need heavy doses of sprays to fix it!”)

This isn’t hard for most people.  What’s nicer than a walk around the garden a couple of times a week, either first thing in the morning, perhaps before dinner, or even in the evening twilight?

Back in the day when I kept crazy hours, I was even known to garden under lights!  While I’m not one to suggest such craziness, I do know it’s probably what kept me sane during those 80 hour weeks!

While no one is suggesting that large-scale organic farming is as relaxing as a walk around an organic garden, neither is anyone suggesting that weekly or bi-weekly spraying of pesticides and herbicides, along with the precautions that need to be taken when doing that, a good or relaxing thing.  Further, being indebted to seed companies for genetically modified seed can also lead to unwarranted stresses.

Obviously not everyone will be able or willing to convert to this type of system.  But if even some farms do convert, what a good thing it would be!

2 thoughts on “What’s Wrong With This Picture?

  1. ddonabella November 5, 2012 / 9:10 am

    This so exciting to hear…our big grocery chain Wegmans has an organic farm S of Rochester NY. They have been experimenting for years with organic growing and farming…they wanted to see if it was profitable and sustainable…verdict was yes and yes. So they are now educating farmers to change them to organics so they can provide more locally grown organics…I hope this continues as that is all I eat if I can find them.

    • gardendaze November 5, 2012 / 9:57 am

      Donna,
      You are so lucky to have a Wegmans. I visited one while I was in New Jersey once and I was so impressed! We have Whole Foods here but I can’t shop there for everything. We also have Trader Joe’s, who has a lot of organic stuff but as you may know, their organics are controversial because they do not disclose their sources so that it’s difficult to confirm.
      My own experiences–on a very tiny scale–made me believe that this study had to be right. But it’s so nice to have validation.

      Thanks for reading!

      Karla

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s